Abstract
PURPOSE AND BACKGROUND: Diffusion tensor imaging (DTI) is an MR imaging–based technique that provides an in vivo tool for visualization of white matter tracts. In this preliminary study, we used this technique to investigate the diffusion characteristics of white matter tracts in patients with hydrocephalus before and after surgery and compared them with age-matched volunteers.
MATERIALS AND METHODS: Seven patients with different types of acute hydrocephalus (defined by acute clinical signs of increased intracranial pressure and imaging evidence of enlarged ventricles) underwent MR imaging including a DTI protocol before and after surgery for shunt placement/revision or ventriculostomy. Eight age-matched healthy subjects served as a control group. The DTI was acquired in a clinical setting that included 6 gradient directions with a b value of 1000 s/mm2.
RESULTS: Before surgery, in fiber systems lateral to the ventricles (corona radiata), the diffusion parallel to the fibers was increased (+10%) and the diffusion perpendicular to the fibers was decreased (−25%) in all patients, resulting in an overall increase in the fractional diffusion anisotropy (FA, +28%). Following surgery, the FA values approached those of control values in all except 1 patient. In the corpus callosum, the presurgery FA values in patients with hydrocephalus (HCP) were lower than those of control values, and no significant changes were seen following surgery.
CONCLUSIONS: DTI can distinguish the compression characteristics of white matter before and after surgery in patients with HCP. At the acute stage of the disease, DTI characteristics point to white matter compression as a possible cause of the observed changes.
Increased intracranial pressure (ICP) is a major consequence of many intracranial pathologies, manifesting in headaches, vomiting, papilledema, and pupillary dilation due to herniation in extreme cases.1,2 Increased ICP is frequently found in association with space-occupying lesions (tumors, hematomas, and abscesses), brain edema, and hydrocephalus (HCP),1–5 conditions that can cause mechanical pressure and compression of brain tissue. To date, noninvasive imaging techniques such as MR imaging have been unable to evaluate ICP.6 In HCP, conventional MR imaging sequences can demonstrate ventricular size and suggest areas of compressed tissue but cannot estimate local tension or pressure on the adjacent fibers.
The anatomic presence of ventriculomegaly by itself is not sufficient to diagnose HCP,1,5 which by definition includes enlargement of ventricles with clinical symptoms and signs of elevated intracranial pressure. Differentiation of ventriculomegaly and the HCP syndrome can be difficult in patients with chronic conditions in whom enlarged ventricles have existed for a long time and/or clinical symptoms are subtle. Although HCP may require prompt surgical treatment, ventriculomegaly without elevated pressure may represent an old or compensated condition that should be followed conservatively.
One can assume that increased ICP due to fluid accumulation in acute HCP leads to pressure on white matter pathways, especially those located around the ventricles.3,7,8 Studies have shown that even chronic pressure to the white matter can lead to significant loss of neuronal transmission, demyelination, and axonal loss resulting in irreversible disability.9–11 Diffusion tensor imaging (DTI) is an MR imaging–based technique that characterizes white matter.12–16 DTI extracts the principal diffusivities (parallel and perpendicular to the fibers), the mean diffusivity (apparent diffusion coefficient [ADC]), and the fractional anisotropy (FA)—a measure of the difference between each of the principal diffusivities and the their mean.13 The FA images provide very high contrast between gray and white matter: white matter appears hyperintense and gray matter, hypointense.
In contrast to the large number of studies on brain diseases with DTI, the technique has been used in only a few investigations of white matter compression (as happens in HCP).17,18 Wieshmann et al showed that DTI can help delineate the displaced white matter and suggested that increased anisotropy might be related to white matter compression.17,18 We undertook to evaluate whether changes in DTI indices before and after surgery can be used as a marker of white matter compression in HCP. To the best of our knowledge, this is the first study of the diffusion characteristics of pressed/tensed white matter tracts in HCP before and after surgery.
Methods
Patients.
Seven patients with acute HCP and 8 age-matched healthy volunteers with no history of neurologic diseases, the control group, underwent MR imaging including DTI protocol. The patients with HCP underwent MR imaging before and after surgical intervention. Postsurgery MR imaging was performed at least 3 months following surgery to allow for re-adjustment of the tissue and intracranial pressure. Although MR imaging was performed as part of the clinical assessments, the local institutional review board committee approved the MR imaging protocol, and informed consent was obtained from all participants or their parents/guardian. The patients’ clinical and neurologic information is summarized in the Table.
Imaging Acquisition.
MR imaging was performed on a 1.5T or 3T Signa scanner (GE Healthcare, Milwaukee, Wis) with a conventional quadrature head coil. The field of view in all MR imaging scans was 24 cm, and the section thickness was 3 mm with no gap between sections. In addition to several clinical sequences, the MR imaging protocol also included a T2-weight series (fast spin-echo pulse sequence with TR/TE, 5000/102 ms) and a DTI protocol. The DTI dataset was acquired by using a spin-echo diffusion-weighted echo-planar imaging sequence with the following parameters: TR/TE, 10000/98 ms; Δ/δ, 31/25 ms and gmax of 2.2 gauss/cm (for the 1.5T scanner); Δ/δ, 24/18 ms and gmax of 3.4 gauss/cm (for the 3T scanner); matrix dimension of 128 × 128, with 3 averages. The diffusion images were acquired along 6 noncollinear diffusion gradient directions with a maximal b value of 1000 s/mm2. The DTI dataset consisted of 7 images (6 diffusion-weighted images and 1 with no applied diffusion gradients). The total acquisition time for the entire DTI dataset was 4 minutes.
Data Analysis.
Before the diffusion tensor computation, all images were corrected for eddy current distortion and rigid-body brain motion by using the approach of Rohde et al.19 Images were corrected by using a mutual information-based registration technique including a spatial transformation model for correcting eddy current–induced image distortion and head movements.19 DTI analysis was performed as described by Basser and Pierpaoli.12 Following image registration, 4 DTI-based images were used for region of interest (ROI)–based analysis: FA, ADC, λ⊥ (radial diffusivity, perpendicular to the fibers, represented by the smallest eigenvalue), and λ// (parallel diffusivity, along the fibers, represented by the largest eigenvalue) images. ROIs were selected anatomically at the posterior limb of the internal capsule, the optic radiation, the superior longitudinal fascicules, the genu and splenium of the corpus callosum, the subcortical frontal white matter, and the subcortical temporal white matter. For each fiber system, ROIs were selected in at least 3 sections in which these fiber systems could be identified for each of the hemispheres. Because no statistical differences were found between left and right hemisphere data, we combined the information from both; thus, for each subject, numeric values of the different indices (FA, ADC, λ⊥, and λ//) were obtained by averaging the data from the 6 ROIs (3 per hemisphere).
Figure 1 is an example of ROI selection in a control subject and an HCP subject. To help with region of interest placement, we used color-coded FA maps in which white matter structures can be identified more easily.15 In those maps, fibers crossing from left to right are visualized in red; those crossing posteroanteriorly are visualized in green; and those crossing inferosuperiorly, in blue. This methodology enables identification of a significant amount of well-documented white matter fiber systems.20 Despite the significant displacement of the fibers by enlarged ventricles in our patients with HCP, the previously mentioned structures could be identified. An example is shown in Fig 1G, -H, in which ROI selections are shown for the patient with the largest ventricles (patient 3 in the Table). Comparison between the ROI groups (acute HCP → healthy controls; presurgery [acute] HCP → postsurgery HCP) was done by using the Student t test.
Results
Acute HCP was generally characterized by increased FA in areas of compressed white matter. Figure 2 shows the axial view of the ADC and FA images of 2 patients with HCP (Fig 2B, -C, and-E, -F, respectively) and a control subject (Fig 2A, -D) at the level of the internal capsule. Arrows point to significantly increased FA areas in the patients with acute HCP (Fig 2E, -F). In contrast, the ADC maps showed no significant differences between patients with HCP and control subjects. In contrast to the findings in fibers lateral to the ventricles, the corpus callosum parts (the body, the genu, and the splenium) that lie above the ventricles exhibited slightly reduced values of FA in patients with acute HCP compared with the control subjects. These areas were also characterized by increased ADC. Figure 3 shows the midsagittal view of the brain demonstrating the corpus callosum for a control subject and 2 patients with acute HCP. There is a marked reduction in the anisotropy, especially in the area of the genu (enlarged in the color scale) in the patients with HCP. The splenium was barely visible in most patients with HCP and could not be analyzed. Except for the internal capsule and the genu of the corpus callosum, other ROIs (superior longitudinal fascicules, subcortical frontal white matter, subcortical temporal white matter, and optic radiation) showed less significant changes.
Figure 4 summarizes the ROI analysis for the internal capsule and the genu of the corpus callosum. In the internal capsule (Fig 4A, -B), the FA was 0.74 ± 0.11 for the group with acute HCP and 0.58 ± 0.03 for the control group. The ADC did not differ significantly between the 2 groups: 0.67 ± 0.01 and 0.70 ± 0.03 for the control and HCP groups, respectively. In the genu of the corpus callosum (Fig 4C, -D), the FA was 0.47 ± 0.08 for the acute HCP group and 0.72 ± 0.03 for the control group. In this region, the ADC was higher for the HCP group than for the control group: 0.98 ± 0.13 × 10−5 cm2/sec versus 0.76 ± 0.03 × 10−5 cm2/sec, respectively. Other regions (superior longitudinal fascicules, subcortical temporal white matter, subcortical frontal white matter, and optic radiation) followed the trend of the internal capsule, but differences were slight and not statistically significant.
Six of the 7 patients with HCP underwent MR imaging before and after shunt implantation or endoscopic surgery. All except 1 patient (patient 3, Table) showed improvement in clinical signs following surgery and significant changes in the diffusion parameters. A considerable reduction in the FA was observed in most analyzed regions (including the internal capsule, corona radiata, optic radiation, and superior longitudinal fascicules). Again, the most striking effect was in the internal capsule and corona radiata, but other areas exhibited a noticeable decline as well. Figure 5 shows ADC and FA maps of a patient with HCP before and after surgery. The 2 MR imaging scans were registered; therefore, the sections are at similar locations. The shrinkage in CSF volume following surgery is apparent in the ADC images. The reduction in FA is apparent in the internal capsule area (the left internal capsule is magnified in the color scale). Figure 5E, -F shows ADC and FA ROI analyses for the internal capsule: the FA decreased from 0.72 ± 0.03 before surgery to 0.61 ± 0.04 after surgery, and the ADC remained nearly the same. For this patient, only the superior longitudinal fascicules showed a similar trend of FA reduction (from 0.55 ± 0.04 to 0.50 ± 0.06), whereas other regions stayed the same (the optic radiation, the splenium of the corpus callosum, the genu of the corpus callosum, the subcortical frontal white matter, and the subcortical temporal white matter) before and after surgery. Figure 6 shows this analysis for another patient. Like the previous patient, FA values decreased from 0.65 ± 0.03 before surgery to 0.52 ± 0.07 after surgery at the level of the internal capsule, whereas ADC values remained constant. Other regions showed no significant changes for this patient.
To learn more about the origin of the FA changes in acute HCP signs, we decomposed the FA into its diffusivities (λ⊥ and λ//) and analyzed each one separately. Areas of increased anisotropy showed reduced diffusivity perpendicular to the fibers and increased diffusivity parallel to the fibers. This resulted in an increase in the overall FA and no net change in the ADC. Figure 7 graphically summarizes these observations. Figure 7A depicts the perpendicular diffusivity of patients with acute HCP and the control group before and after surgery averaged across all subjects and patients. A significant increase in perpendicular diffusivity to normal values was seen after surgery (P < .05, paired t test). The same analysis for the parallel diffusivity (Fig 7B) showed a significant reduction in the diffusivity after surgery, albeit not to control values. To overcome intersubject variability, expressed by the large error bars, we normalized each subject to the presurgery values (Fig 7C). This analysis revealed a highly significant increase of ∼25% in the radial diffusivity after surgery, accompanied by a significant decrease of ∼10% in the parallel diffusivity.
Discussion
The main finding of this study was that the FA was increased in the white matter areas lateral to the ventricles in acute HCP. The increased volume of the CSF in HCP frequently leads to pressure on the most adjacent white fiber pathways: the corona radiata and the corpus callosum.21,22 In the corona radiata, we observed a significant increase in the FA (especially in the internal capsule), evidenced by an increase in the parallel diffusivity and a decrease in the radial diffusivity (Figs 2 and 4). The opposite trend was observed in the corpus callosum: reduced FA, reduced parallel diffusivity, and increased radial diffusivity (Figs 3 and 4). In fact, the corpus callosum in patients with HCP had diffusion characteristics similar to degenerated white matter tissue. Pre- and postsurgery examinations of the patients with HCP revealed significant improvement after surgery in the FA values (especially of the internal capsule), which approximated control values (Figs 5 and 6). Postsurgery DTI showed no changes in diffusion characteristics of the corpus callosum.
Increased Versus Decreased FA
Most DTI studies on neuronal diseases and disorders report reduced FA generally associated with neuronal degeneration, as in multiple sclerosis, or edema, as in stroke.22–30 In those diseases, the FA reduction is accompanied by an increase in ADC and a dramatic elevation in the radial diffusivity values.31–33 In patients with HCP, such diffusion characteristics are found in the corpus callosum, leading to the assumption that the corpus callosum undergoes neuronal degeneration. Studies on pathology of the corpus callosum in acute and chronic HCP support this observation.34–36
In contrast to FA reduction in the corpus callosum in acute HCP, the FA is increased in white matter lateral to the ventricles. A marked decrease in the radial diffusivity accompanied by an increase in the parallel diffusivity caused the ADC values to remain at control levels because ADC averages all diffusivities. Similar results were found on diffusivity analyses of displaced white matter by brain tumors.37 From these observations, it can be assumed that direct pressure to the white matter affects the white matter architecture in a way that causes the FA to increase.
The different pattern of changes in the internal capsule and the genu of the corpus callosum might represent different pathophysiologic mechanisms. Because all our patients were clinically diagnosed with acute HCP, it is reasonable to assume that high ICP was present in all of them (although not monitored). If the previous assumptions about the mechanisms that cause the FA changes (ie, degeneration for reduced FA and displacement of increased FA) are true, one can speculate that the corpus callosum is the tissue most affected by the enlarged ventricles (because it is located just above them) and therefore degenerates more rapidly. The corona radiata, which lies lateral to the ventricles, might experience milder pressure than the corpus callosum and, therefore, appear as only displaced. Even in cases of chronic HCP (arrested HCP), other studies found that the white matter is also degenerated in the lateral fiber systems.
Possible Mechanism of Increased FA
A possible explanation for the observed increased FA in acute HCP is the morphologic changes that occur in fiber architecture under mechanical pressure (which probably happens in HCP). For homogeneously aligned white matter fibers, mechanical pressure will cause higher packing of the fibers and increased fiber density per unit area. Higher axonal density will increase the tortuosity of water molecules, which might lead to overall reduction in the measured radial diffusivity. This increased tortuosity should be a direct consequence of extracellular tissue shrinkage and is expected to happen in compression. Indeed, this is observed in stroke, in which cytotoxic edema leads to extracellular space shrinkage and overall slowed diffusivity.23
In contrast to the radial diffusivity, which is influenced by the geometric packing of the fibers, the parallel diffusivity is relatively free of obstacles. Nevertheless, we observed an increase in the parallel diffusivity under mechanical pressure. This might reflect stretching of the fibers to be more linearly aligned, resulting in fewer obstacles to diffusion and faster diffusion. Indeed, the effect parallel to the fibers was found to be smaller than that on the radial diffusivity (10% versus 25%).
Limits of the Application of DTI in Increased ICP
Increased ICP may also happen in cases in which no mechanical pressure is apparent (eg, pseudotumor cerebri). Assuming that the changes observed in acute HCP are a result of the changes to the microarchitecture of the fibers (ie, a secondary effect of the increased ventricles size), it is unlikely that such changes will be found in cases of increased ICP without massive tissue compression. Moreover, although increased FA was also found in space-occupying lesions, in which the adjacent tissue is obviously compressed by the lesion volume,37 other white matter areas in the brain of such patients show normal FA and diffusivity, though they undergo significant pressure.
Thus, increased FA might be a unique characteristic of acute HCP and could serve as a diagnostic criterion, but one must take into account the patients with HCP in whom the enlarged ventricles represent a chronic condition of the brain. Such patients, often referred to as having “arrested HCP,” show no clinical symptoms of increased ICP. The brain in these cases has most probably compensated for loss of space by increased tissue density (ie, more white matter fibers per unit area). Some of these patients may have a high FA as well. On the other hand, long exposure of the tissue to unnatural compression could result in tissue degeneration,35 throwing into question whether DTI can characterize arrested HCP.
Future Work
This preliminary study raises questions about ICP and white matter. One question is the appearance of DTI in patients with arrested HCP: can DTI distinguish between arrested HCP and acute HCP? If so, DTI could become a powerful tool for radiologic assessment and management of HCP. Another question is whether our findings can be generalized to other ages. Our study included patients older than 9 years even though most patients with HCP are in early childhood. This age cohort was chosen for 3 reasons: 1) FA changes stemming from normal development are relatively minor after the age of 5–6 years,38 so any changes in FA in an individual can be attributed only to the surgical intervention and not to other developmental factors. 2) The study of young patients with HCP is complicated by development-related FA changes, in addition to those caused by the enlarged ventricles. 3) The recruitment of an age-matched control group for young patients is difficult. Thus, future studies on the efficacy of using DTI in HCP will have to include a large number of patients and control subjects with a wide range of ages. Last, a study should be performed on both arrested and treated patients with HCP, in whom the diffusion parameters are evaluated for a long period of time (a few years) in the same brain region. Such a study will contribute to the assessment of tissue degeneration in chronic (arrested) and short-term HCP.
Conclusions
The fact that DTI shows 2 patterns of changes (increased versus decreased FA) raises speculation about the micron-scale changes of the tissue and the pathophysiologic mechanisms it undergoes in HCP. The measurement and analysis of the principal diffusivities together with FA offer the possibility to follow and characterize pressure effects on white matter tracts in HCP. The demonstration that DTI can quantify changes before and after surgery might give the radiologist a tool with which to estimate tissue recovery, and it can give the neurosurgeon an indicator, in addition to clinical improvement, of the effectiveness of surgery, especially in patients in whom there is a decrease in ICP with no evident decrease in the size of the ventricles, as often happens after endoscopic surgeries.
Acknowledgments
This research was supported by the Israel Science Foundation, grant no. 1280/04.
References
- Received December 2, 2005.
- Accepted after revision December 14, 2005.
- Copyright © American Society of Neuroradiology