Abstract
SUMMARY: CSF-venous fistula is a recently reported cause of spontaneous intracranial hypotension that may occur in the absence of myelographic evidence of CSF leak. Information about this entity is currently very limited, but it is of potential importance given the large percentage of cases of spontaneous intracranial hypotension associated with negative myelography findings. We report 3 additional cases of CSF-venous fistula and describe the “hyperdense paraspinal vein” sign, which may aid in its detection.
ABBREVIATION:
- SIH
- spontaneous intracranial hypotension
Spontaneous intracranial hypotension is thought to result from leakage of CSF from the spinal thecal sac, but in approximately half of cases, no leak is seen on myelography.1,2 Patients may be treated with prolonged bed rest or nontargeted lumbar epidural blood patch, but these therapies may not be successful in a substantial proportion of patients.1,3 In cases in which targeted treatment is desired (such as when nontargeted lumbar epidural blood patch fails), these cases of SIH with no myelographic evidence of CSF leak can be very challenging, and the inability to determine the site of the leak may preclude effective treatment. It has been previously presumed that these cases may be the result of intermittent or very slow-flow CSF leaks.
Recently, it has been recognized that direct fistulas between CSF and paraspinal veins can be a cause of SIH with negative findings on myelography. In a series of 3 patients, Schievink et al4 reported the presence of such CSF-venous fistulas, diagnosed by using digital subtraction myelography. Two of these cases had negative findings on CT myelography, meaning that they occurred with no concomitant epidural leak of CSF. Presently, it is unclear how frequently this phenomenon occurs and to what extent it may account for some of the cases of SIH in patients with negative findings on myelography. Furthermore, these lesions were identified with digital subtraction myelography, which is not performed at all institutions, is more commonly used in the setting of high-flow CSF leaks, and typically covers only a portion of the total length of the spine.5,6 Thus, it would be helpful to identify, from clues on cross-sectional imaging, which patients might benefit from a digital subtraction myelogram and where that imaging should be focused to detect these uncommonly recognized, often subtle lesions.
In this Brief Report, we present 3 additional cases of CSF-venous fistulas in patients with SIH and describe a novel imaging sign, the “hyperdense paraspinal vein,” which may assist in CSF-venous fistula localization.
Cases
Case 1.
A 34-year-old woman had new-onset orthostatic headache and back pain. Brain MR imaging showed dural enhancement, brain sagging, and a venous distention sign. Opening pressure measured 0 cm H2O. A blind epidural blood patch improved her symptoms for 2 weeks, but her headaches recurred. CT myelography revealed a focal leak of contrast at the left T8 nerve root (Fig 1). Additionally, a hyperattenuated paraspinal vein was seen at this level, measuring 83–126 HU. The same vein on nonmyelographic CT images measured 27–34 HU. Targeted patching by using blood and fibrin glue was performed at this level but did not result in durable relief. A dynamic myelogram was then obtained, whereby the patient was placed in the left lateral decubitus position with the table tilted feet-down, contrast was injected into the thecal sac, the patient was then slowly tilted head-down, and the contrast passage was monitored by using intermittent fluoroscopy and spot radiographs. This study demonstrated no epidural fluid collection, but there was evidence of a CSF-venous fistula, with myelographic contrast identified in the adjacent paraspinal vein. The patient was taken to the operating room, where a hemilaminectomy was performed to expose the nerve root. No free epidural CSF leakage was seen, but an abnormal enlarged vein was seen connecting to a CSF-filled diverticulum of the nerve root, which was coagulated and divided. Following the operation, the positional headache immediately resolved and had not recurred at 4-month follow-up.
A 34-year-old woman with SIH. A, Coronal image from a CT myelogram shows a low-flow CSF leak inferior to the left T8 nerve root (arrow). B, A subsequent dynamic myelogram obtained with the patient in the left lateral decubitus position shows the area of the leak (arrow) with a fistula to an adjacent paraspinal vein (arrowhead). C, Axial image from her original CT myelogram reveals a hyperattenuated paraspinal vein (arrow). D, Postprocessed image with thresholded color overlay depicting attenuation values from 60 to 140 HU helps improve the conspicuity of this hyperattenuated vein.
Case 2.
A 56-year-old man with new-onset positional headaches associated with neck and interscapular pain. Brain MR imaging showed dural enhancement, brain sagging, a venous distention sign, and bilateral subdural collections. Opening pressure measured 3 cm H20. Nontargeted lumbar epidural blood patch only helped his symptoms for a few hours. CT myelogram revealed a small focus of CSF leakage adjacent to the right nerve root sleeve at T10–11 (Fig 2). A hyperattenuated paraspinal vein was seen at this level, measuring 93–146 HU. The same vein on nonmyelographic CT images measured 14–32 HU. Targeted patching by using blood and fibrin glue was performed, which only provided 5 days of relief. He re-presented with new subdural hemorrhages and underwent repeat targeted patching 2 additional times during the next month, again without durable relief. He was then taken to the operating room, where a hemilaminectomy was performed to expose the nerve root. No dural defect or CSF leak was seen; however, prominent veins surrounding the nerve root were identified and coagulated. Following surgery, the positional headaches immediately resolved and had not recurred at 2-year follow-up.
A 56-year-old man with SIH. A, Axial image from a CT myelogram shows a low-flow CSF leak in the right neural foramen at T10–11 (arrowhead). An adjacent hyperattenuated paraspinal vein (arrow) is seen. B, Postprocessed image with thresholded color overlay depicting attenuation values from 60 to 140 HU improves the conspicuity of this hyperattenuated vein (arrow). C, Coronal image with thresholded color overlay demonstrates that only the vein at the level and side of the fistula (arrow) shows increased attenuation.
Case 3.
A 59-year-old woman presented with 5 years of positional headache, neck and bilateral upper extremity pain, and tinnitus. Brain MR imaging showed dural enhancement, brain sagging, and a venous distention sign. Opening pressure measured 10.2 cm H2O. A previous blind epidural blood patch did not produce durable relief. CT myelography revealed extensive nerve root sleeve diverticula but no evidence of a CSF leak. A hyperattenuated paraspinal vein was present on the right at T6–7, measuring 85–101 HU (Fig 3). The same vein on nonmyelographic CT images measured 29 HU. She underwent epidural patching by using blood and fibrin glue targeted at multiple nerve root sleeve diverticula on 3 occasions, but her symptoms recurred each time. A digital subtraction myelogram was then obtained, by using the technique previously described,6 revealing a CSF-venous fistula on the right at T6–7. At the operation, a very thin-walled cyst was encountered, to which was attached an extensive venous plexus. The plexus was carefully dissected free and then cauterized. No dural defect was seen intraoperatively. Her positional headaches resolved after surgery and had not recurred at 15-month follow-up.
A 59-year-old woman with SIH. A, Axial image from a CT myelogram shows a hyperattenuated paraspinal vein (arrow) at T6–7 on the right. B, A subsequent digital subtraction myelogram shows a CSF-venous fistula at this location (arrow). C, Postprocessed image with thresholded color overlay depicting attenuation values from 60 to 140 HU again helps with the identification of this finding (arrow). D, Axial image from an adjacent level (T8–9) where there was no fistula is provided for comparison. Note that the paraspinal vein is not hyperattenuated (arrowhead) and is not identified on the thresholded color overlay.
Discussion
In this report, we present radiologic and surgical confirmation of the presence of CSF-venous fistulas as an etiology for SIH, first reported in a recent small case series of 3 patients by Schievink et al.4 Confirmation of this entity is important in that it identifies an alternative mechanism of CSF volume loss leading to the clinical syndrome of SIH. For the estimated 46%–55% of patients with SIH with no evidence of CSF leakage on myelography,1,2 the identification of a fistula may provide the opportunity for targeted treatment. On the basis of our limited experience with CSF-venous fistulas, we have found them to be generally unresponsive to epidural patching, ultimately requiring surgical intervention to obliterate the fistula and its draining veins.
Our series also suggests that CT myelography may provide some clues as to the presence and location of the fistula. In all 3 of our cases, after intrathecal contrast was administered, a hyperattenuated paraspinal vein was identified in close proximity to the site where the CSF fistula was ultimately localized. The average attenuation of the hyperattenuated vessel on postmyelographic CT measured 105.7 ± 23.0 HU, compared with attenuation values of 27.5 ± 6.4 HU for the same vessel on nonmyelographic CT (ie, CT performed without intrathecal myelographic contrast).
The conspicuity of this sign was improved by the use of image postprocessing with commercially available software (Aquarius iNtuition, Version 4.4.11; TeraRecon, San Mateo, California). Image thresholding with color overlay was used to highlight CT attenuation values of 60–140 HU; this range was selected empirically on the basis of observed attenuation values in the hyperattenuated-appearing veins compared with normal-appearing paraspinal veins at other levels.
This “hyperdense paraspinal vein” sign presumably represents rapid passage of myelographic contrast into the venous system through the fistula. Under normal conditions, CSF reabsorption into the bloodstream happens at the level of spinal nerve roots, driven by a pressure gradient across arachnoid villi by means of vacuoles that traverse the wall of the villus in a unidirectional manner.7⇓–9 CSF-venous fistulas may represent focal rupture or failure of these villi, resulting in persistent, unregulated CSF loss.
Identification of this sign not only suggests that a fistula is present but also aids in its localization. This finding is potentially important because the subtle imaging appearance associated with many of the reported cases of CSF-venous fistula may make them difficult to detect on conventional myelography or digital subtraction myelography unless their presence is suspected, and not all patients with SIH will undergo digital subtraction myelography because its use has previously been generally restricted to a limited number of medical centers where it is typically used for the localization of high-flow CSF leaks.5 As future cases of CSF-venous fistulas are identified, it will be useful to determine the sensitivity of this imaging sign, whether there are false-positive causes of hyperattenuated paraspinal veins, whether this entity is ever seen outside of the context of SIH, and whether other imaging techniques or image postprocessing may aid in its detection.
REFERENCES
- Received October 28, 2015.
- Accepted after revision December 4, 2015.
- © 2016 by American Journal of Neuroradiology
Jump to section
Related Articles
Cited By...
- Postsurgical Recurrence of CSF-Venous Fistulas in Spontaneous Intracranial Hypotension
- A Novel Endovascular Therapy for CSF Hypotension Secondary to CSF-Venous Fistulas
- Spinal CSF-Venous Fistulas in Morbidly and Super Obese Patients with Spontaneous Intracranial Hypotension
- Decubitus CT Myelography for CSF-Venous Fistulas: A Procedural Approach
- Spontaneous Intracranial Hypotension: Atypical Radiologic Appearances, Imaging Mimickers, and Clinical Look-Alikes
- MR Myelography for the Detection of CSF-Venous Fistulas
- Renal Excretion of Contrast on CT Myelography: A Specific Marker of CSF Leak
- Clinical Reasoning: An underrecognized etiology of new daily persistent headache
- Decubitus CT Myelography for Detecting Subtle CSF Leaks in Spontaneous Intracranial Hypotension
- Renal Contrast on CT Myelography: Diagnostic Value in Patients with Spontaneous Intracranial Hypotension