Regular ArticleNon-Mono-Exponential Attenuation of Water andN-Acetyl Aspartate Signals Due to Diffusion in Brain Tissue☆
Abstract
Diffusion measurements were performed on water andN-acetyl aspartate (NAA) molecules in excised brain tissue using a wide range ofb-values (up to 28.3 × 106and 35.8 × 106s cm−2for water and NAA, respectively). The attenuation of the signals of water and NAA due to diffusion was measured at fixed diffusion times (tD). These measurements, in which the echo time (TE) was set to 70 ms, were repeated for several diffusion times ranging from 35 to 305 ms. Signal attenuations were fitted to mono-, bi-, and triexponential functions to obtain the apparent diffusion coefficients (ADCs) of these molecules at each diffusion time. From these experiments the following observations and conclusions were made: (1) Signal attenuation of water and NAA due to diffusion over the entire range ofbvalues examined is not monoexponential and the extracted ADCs depend on the diffusion time; (2) In the case of water the experimental data are best fitted by a triexponential function, while forbvalues up to 1 × 106s cm−2, a biexponential function seems to reproduce the experimental data as well as the triexponential function; (3) If only the low range ofbvalues are fitted (up to 0.5 × 106s cm−2) signal attenuation of water is monoexponential and insensitive totD; (4) Water ADCs decreased with the increase intDbut the relative population of the fast diffusing component increases such that at atDof 305 ms there is nearly a single population; (5) The major fast diffusion component of the water shows only very limited restriction; (6) NAA signal attenuation is biexponential and analysis of the lowb-value range gives only monoexponential decay, but the obtained ADC is sensitive to the diffusion time; (7) The ADCs obtained from fitting the data with a biexponential function decrease as diffusion time increases; (8) The relative population of the slow-diffusing component decreases with increasingtD; (9) Both the fast and the slow diffusing components of NAA show a considerable restriction by what seems to be a nonpermeable barrier from which two compartments, one of 7–8 μm and one of ∼1 μm, were calculated using the Einstein equation. It is suggested that the two compartments represent the NAA in cell bodies and in the intra-axonal space. The effect of the range of thebvalue used in the diffusion experiments on the results is discussed and used to reconcile some of the apparent discrepancies obtained in different experiments concerning water diffusion in brain tissue. The potential of NAA diffusion experiments to probe cellular structure is discussed.
References (55)
- Y. Assaf et al.
Magn. Reson. Imaging
(1997) - D.G. Norris et al.
Magn. Reson. Imaging
(1994) - P.C.M. Van Zijl et al.
- Y. Assaf et al.
J. Magn. Reson. B
(1996) - J. Karger et al.
Adv. Magn. Reson.
(1988) - L.P.H. Leenen et al.
Brain Res.
(1985) - D. Le Bihan et al.
Radiology
(1986) - D. Le Bihan et al.
Radiology
(1988) - D. Le Bihan
Diffusion and Perfusion Magnetic Resonance Imaging
(1995) - M.E. Moseley et al.
Magn. Reson. Med.
(1990)
Am. J. Neuroradiol.
Neurology
Neurology
Stroke
Stroke
Cerebrovasc. Brain Metab. Rev.
Stroke
J. Neurosurg.
Magn. Reson. Med.
Magn. Reson. Med.
Stroke
J. Cereb. Blood Flow Metab.
11th Annual Meeting of the Society of Magnetic Resonance in Medicine
NMR Biomed.
Magn. Reson. Med.
NMR Biomed.
Magn. Reson. Med.
Cited by (192)
Neurite Exchange Imaging ((NEXI): A minimal model of diffusion in gray matter with inter-compartment water exchange
2022, NeuroImageBiophysical models of diffusion in white matter have been center-stage over the past two decades and are essentially based on what is now commonly referred to as the “Standard Model” (SM) of non-exchanging anisotropic compartments with Gaussian diffusion. In this work, we focus on diffusion MRI in gray matter, which requires rethinking basic microstructure modeling blocks. In particular, at least three contributions beyond the SM need to be considered for gray matter: water exchange across the cell membrane – between neurites and the extracellular space; non-Gaussian diffusion along neuronal and glial processes – resulting from structural disorder; and signal contribution from soma. For the first contribution, we propose Neurite Exchange Imaging (NEXI) as an extension of the SM of diffusion, which builds on the anisotropic Kärger model of two exchanging compartments. Using datasets acquired at multiple diffusion weightings (b) and diffusion times (t) in the rat brain in vivo, we investigate the suitability of NEXI to describe the diffusion signal in the gray matter, compared to the other two possible contributions. Our results for the diffusion time window 20–45 ms show minimal diffusivity time-dependence and more pronounced kurtosis decay with time, which is well fit by the exchange model. Moreover, we observe lower signal for longer diffusion times at high b. In light of these observations, we identify exchange as the mechanism that best explains these signal signatures in both low-b and high-b regime, and thereby propose NEXI as the minimal model for gray matter microstructure mapping. We finally highlight multi-b multi-t acquisition protocols as being best suited to estimate NEXI model parameters reliably. Using this approach, we estimate the inter-compartment water exchange time to be 15 – 60 ms in the rat cortex and hippocampus in vivo, which is of the same order or shorter than the diffusion time in typical diffusion MRI acquisitions. This suggests water exchange as an essential component for interpreting diffusion MRI measurements in gray matter.
In vivo Correlation Tensor MRI reveals microscopic kurtosis in the human brain on a clinical 3T scanner
2022, NeuroImageDiffusion MRI (dMRI) has become one of the most important imaging modalities for noninvasively probing tissue microstructure. Diffusional Kurtosis MRI (DKI) quantifies the degree of non-Gaussian diffusion, which in turn has been shown to increase sensitivity towards, e.g., disease and orientation mapping in neural tissue. However, the specificity of DKI is limited as different sources can contribute to the total intravoxel diffusional kurtosis, including: variance in diffusion tensor magnitudes (Kiso), variance due to diffusion anisotropy (Kaniso), and microscopic kurtosis (μK) related to restricted diffusion, microstructural disorder, and/or exchange. Interestingly, μK is typically ignored in diffusion MRI signal modelling as it is assumed to be negligible in neural tissues. However, recently, Correlation Tensor MRI (CTI) based on Double-Diffusion-Encoding (DDE) was introduced for kurtosis source separation, revealing non negligible μK in preclinical imaging. Here, we implemented CTI for the first time on a clinical 3T scanner and investigated the sources of total kurtosis in healthy subjects. A robust framework for kurtosis source separation in humans is introduced, followed by estimation of μK (and the other kurtosis sources) in the healthy brain. Using this clinical CTI approach, we find that μK significantly contributes to total diffusional kurtosis both in grey and white matter tissue but, as expected, not in the ventricles. The first μK maps of the human brain are presented, revealing that the spatial distribution of μK provides a unique source of contrast, appearing different from isotropic and anisotropic kurtosis counterparts. Moreover, group average templates of these kurtosis sources have been generated for the first time, which corroborated our findings at the underlying individual-level maps. We further show that the common practice of ignoring μK and assuming the multiple Gaussian component approximation for kurtosis source estimation introduces significant bias in the estimation of other kurtosis sources and, perhaps even worse, compromises their interpretation. Finally, a twofold acceleration of CTI is discussed in the context of potential future clinical applications. We conclude that CTI has much potential for future in vivo microstructural characterizations in healthy and pathological tissue.
Noninvasively detecting and characterizing modulations in cellular scale micro-architecture remains a desideratum for contemporary neuroimaging. Diffusion MRI (dMRI) has become the mainstay methodology for probing microstructure, and, in ischemia, its contrasts have revolutionized stroke management. Diffusion kurtosis imaging (DKI) has been shown to significantly enhance the sensitivity of stroke detection compared to its diffusion tensor imaging (DTI) counterparts. However, the interpretation of DKI remains ambiguous as its contrast may arise from competing kurtosis sources related to the anisotropy of tissue components, diffusivity variance across components, and microscopic kurtosis (e.g., arising from cross-sectional variance, structural disorder, and restriction). Resolving these sources may be fundamental for developing more specific imaging techniques for stroke management, prognosis, and understanding its pathophysiology. In this study, we apply Correlation Tensor MRI (CTI) – a double diffusion encoding (DDE) methodology recently introduced for deciphering kurtosis sources based on the unique information captured in DDE's diffusion correlation tensors – to investigate the underpinnings of kurtosis measurements in acute ischemic lesions. Simulations for the different kurtosis sources revealed specific signatures for cross-sectional variance (representing neurite beading), edema, and cell swelling. Ex vivo CTI experiments at 16.4 T were then performed in an experimental photothrombotic stroke model 3 h post-stroke (N = 10), and successfully separated anisotropic, isotropic, and microscopic non-Gaussian diffusion sources in the ischemic lesions. Each of these kurtosis sources provided unique contrasts in the stroked area. Particularly, microscopic kurtosis was shown to be a primary “driver” of total kurtosis upon ischemia; its large increases, coupled with decreases in anisotropic kurtosis, are consistent with the expected elevation in cross-sectional variance, likely linked to beading effects in small objects such as neurites. In vivo experiments at 9.4 T at the same time point (3 h post ischemia, N = 5) demonstrated the stability and relevance of the findings and showed that fixation is not a dominant confounder in our findings. In future studies, the different CTI contrasts may be useful to address current limitations of stroke imaging, e.g., penumbra characterization, distinguishing lesion progression form tissue recovery, and elucidating pathophysiological correlates.
Beyond the diffusion standard model in fixed rat spinal cord with combined linear and planar encoding
2021, NeuroImageInformation about tissue on the microscopic and mesoscopic scales can be accessed by modelling diffusion MRI signals, with the aim of extracting microstructure-specific biomarkers. The standard model (SM) of diffusion, currently the most broadly adopted microstructural model, describes diffusion in white matter (WM) tissues by two Gaussian components, one of which has zero radial diffusivity, to represent diffusion in intra- and extra-axonal water, respectively. Here, we reappraise these SM assumptions by collecting comprehensive double diffusion encoded (DDE) MRI data with both linear and planar encodings, which was recently shown to substantially enhance the ability to estimate SM parameters. We find however, that the SM is unable to account for data recorded in fixed rat spinal cord at an ultrahigh field of 16.4 T, suggesting that its underlying assumptions are violated in our experimental data. We offer three model extensions to mitigate this problem: first, we generalize the SM to accommodate finite radii (axons) by releasing the constraint of zero radial diffusivity in the intra-axonal compartment. Second, we include intracompartmental kurtosis to account for non-Gaussian behaviour. Third, we introduce an additional (third) compartment. The ability of these models to account for our experimental data are compared based on parameter feasibility and Bayesian information criterion. Our analysis identifies the three-compartment description as the optimal model. The third compartment exhibits slow diffusion with a minor but non-negligible signal fraction (12%). We demonstrate how failure to take the presence of such a compartment into account severely misguides inferences about WM microstructure. Our findings bear significance for microstructural modelling at large and can impact the interpretation of biomarkers extracted from the standard model of diffusion.
Double diffusion encoding and applications for biomedical imaging
2021, Journal of Neuroscience MethodsDiffusion Magnetic Resonance Imaging (dMRI) is one of the most important contemporary non-invasive modalities for probing tissue structure at the microscopic scale. The majority of dMRI techniques employ standard single diffusion encoding (SDE) measurements, covering different sequence parameter ranges depending on the complexity of the method. Although many signal representations and biophysical models have been proposed for SDE data, they are intrinsically limited by a lack of specificity. Advanced dMRI methods have been proposed to provide additional microstructural information beyond what can be inferred from SDE. These enhanced contrasts can play important roles in characterizing biological tissues, for instance upon diseases (e.g. neurodegenerative, cancer, stroke), aging, learning, and development.
In this review we focus on double diffusion encoding (DDE), which stands out among other advanced acquisitions for its versatility, ability to probe more specific diffusion correlations, and feasibility for preclinical and clinical applications. Various DDE methodologies have been employed to probe compartment sizes (Section 3), decouple the effects of microscopic diffusion anisotropy from orientation dispersion (Section 4), probe displacement correlations, study exchange, or suppress fast diffusing compartments (Section 6). DDE measurements can also be used to improve the robustness of biophysical models (Section 5) and study intra-cellular diffusion via magnetic resonance spectroscopy of metabolites (Section 7). This review discusses all these topics as well as important practical aspects related to the implementation and contrast in preclinical and clinical settings (Section 9) and aims to provide the readers a guide for deciding on the right DDE acquisition for their specific application.
Diffusion weighted imaging based on random Brownian motion of water molecules within a voxel provides information on the micro-structure of biological tissues through water molecule diffusivity. As the electrical conductivity is primarily determined by the concentration and mobility of ionic charge carriers, the macroscopic electrical conductivity of biological tissues is also related to the diffusion of electrical ions. This paper aims to investigate the low-frequency electrical conductivity by relying on a pre-defined biological model that separates the brain into the intracellular (restricted) and extracellular (hindered) compartments. The proposed method uses B1 mapping technique, which provides a high-frequency conductivity distribution at Larmor frequency, and the spherical mean technique, which directly estimates the microscopic tissue structure based on the water molecule diffusivity and neurite orientation distribution. The total extracellular ion concentration, which is separated from the high-frequency conductivity, is recovered using the estimated diffusivity parameters and volume fraction in each compartment. We propose a method to reconstruct the low-frequency dominant conductivity tensor by taking into consideration the extracted extracellular diffusion tensor map and the reconstructed electrical parameters. To demonstrate the reliability of the proposed method, we conducted two phantom experiments. The first one used a cylindrical acrylic cage filled with an agar in the background region and four anomalies for the effect of ion concentration on the electrical conductivity. The other experiment, in which the effect of ion mobility on the conductivity was verified, used cell-like materials with thin insulating membranes suspended in an electrolyte. Animal and human brain experiments were conducted to visualize the low-frequency dominant conductivity tensor images. The proposed method using a conventional MRI scanner can predict the internal current density map in the brain without directly injected external currents.
- ☆
D. Le Bihan
- 1
To whom correspondence should be addressed. Fax: 972-3-6409293. E-mail:[email protected].