Search
Close
Search
Advanced Search
Search Menu

Abstract

Stereotactic biopsy is often performed for diagnostic purposes before treating patients whose imaging studies highly suggest glioma. Indications cited for biopsy include diagnosis and/or the “inoperability” of the tumor. This study questions the routine use of stereotactic biopsy in the initial management of gliomas. At The University of Texas M. D. Anderson Cancer Center, we retrospectively reviewed a consecutive series of 81 patients whose imaging studies suggested glioma and who underwent stereotactic biopsy followed by craniotomy/resection (within 60 days) between 1993 and 1998. All relevant clinical and imaging information was reviewed, including computerized volumetric analysis of the tumors based on pre- and postoperative MRI. Stereotactic biopsy was performed at institutions other than M. D. Anderson in 78 (96%) of 81 patients. The majority of tumors were located either in eloquent brain (36 of 81 = 44%) or near-eloquent brain (41 of 81 = 51%), and this frequently was the rationale cited for performing stereotactic biopsy. Gross total resection (>95%) was achieved in 46 (57%) of 81 patients, with a median extent of resection of 96% for this series. Diagnoses based on biopsy or resection in the same patient differed in 40 (49%) of 82 cases. This discrepancy was reduced to 30 (38%) of 80 cases when the biopsy slides were reviewed preoperatively by each of three neuropathologists at M. D. Anderson. Major neurologic complications occurred in 10 (12.3%) of 81 surgical patients and 3 (3.7%) of 81 patients undergoing biopsy. Surgical morbidity was probably higher in our series than it would be for glioma patients in general because our patients represent a highly selected subset of glioma patients whose tumors present a technical challenge to remove. Stereotactic biopsy is frequently inaccurate in providing a correct diagnosis and is associated with additional risk and cost. If stereotactic biopsy is performed, expert neuropathology consultation should be sought.

References

Abi-Said, D., Lacroix, M., Shi, W., Gokaslan, Z.L., Hess, K., DeMonte, F., Lang, F.F., McCutcheon, I.E., Hassenbusch, S.J., Michael, C., Miller, D., and Sawaya, R. (

1999
) Imaging-based necrosis and the survival of patients with glioblastoma multiforme. Neuro-Oncology [serial online], Doc. N1, September 29, 1999. URL http://neuro-oncology.mc.duke.edu.
Neuro-Oncol.
1
,
294
. (Abstract)

Apuzzo, M.L., Chandrasoma, P.T., Cohen, D., Zee, C.S., and Zelman, V. (

1987
) Computed imaging stereotaxy: Experience and perspective related to 500 procedures applied to brain masses.
Neurosurgery
20
,
930
-937.

Bernstein, M., and Parrent, A.G. (

1994
) Complications of CT-guided stereotactic biopsy of intra-axial brain lesions.
J. Neurosurg.
81
,
165
-168.

Broggi, G., Franzini, A., Giorgi, C., and Allegranza, A. (

1984
) Diagnostic accuracy and multimodal approach in stereotactic biopsies of deep brain tumors.
Acta Neurochir. Suppl.
33
,
211
-212.

Bruner, J.M., Inouye, L., Fuller, G.N., and Langford, L.A. (

1997
) Diagnostic discrepancies and their clinical impact in a neuropathology referral practice.
Cancer
79
,
796
-803.

Chandrasoma, P.T., Smith, M.M., and Apuzzo, M.L. (

1989
) Stereotactic biopsy in the diagnosis of brain masses: Comparison of results of biopsy and resected surgical specimen.
Neurosurgery
24
,
160
-165.

Coffey, R.J., and Lunsford, L.D. (

1985
) Stereotactic surgery for mass lesions of the midbrain and pons.
Neurosurgery
17
,
12
-18.

Danks, R.A., Chopra, G., Gonzales, M.F., Orian, J.M., and Kaye, A.H. (

1995
) Aberrant p53 expression does not correlate with the prognosis in anaplastic astrocytoma.
Neurosurgery
37
,
246
-254.

Devaux, B.C., O'Fallon, J.R., and Kelly, P.J. (

1993
) Resection, biopsy, and survival in malignant glial neoplasms: A retrospective study of clinical parameters, therapy, and outcome.
J. Neurosurg.
78
,
767
-775.

Fadul, C., Wood, J., Thaler, H., Galicich, J., Patterson, R.H., Jr., and Posner, J.B. (

1988
) Morbidity and mortality of craniotomy for excision of supratentorial gliomas.
Neurology
38
,
1374
-1379.

Feiden, W., Steude, U., Bise, K., and Gundisch, O. (

1991
) Accuracy of stereotactic brain tumor biopsy: Comparison of the histologic findings in biopsy cylinders and resected tumor tissue.
Neurosurg. Rev.
14
,
51
-56.

Fuller, G.N. (

1996
) Central nervous system tumors. In: Parham, D.M. (Ed.),
Pediatric Neoplasia: Morphology and Biology
. Philadelphia, Pa.: Lippincott-Raven. pp.
153
-204.

Fulling, K.H., and Nelson, J.S. (

1984
) Cerebral astrocytic neoplasms in the adult: Contribution of histologic examination to the assessment of prognosis.
Semin. Diagn. Pathol.
1
,
152
-163.

Gaudin, P.B., Sherman, M.E., Brat, D.J., Zahurak, M., and Erozan, Y.S. (

1997
) Accuracy of grading gliomas on CT-guided stereotactic biopsies: A survival analysis.
Diagn. Cytopathol.
17
,
461
-466.

Glantz, M.J., Burger, P.C., Herndon, J.E., II, Friedman, A.H., Cairncross, J.G., Vick, N.A., and Schold, S.C., Jr. (

1991
) Influence of the type of surgery on the histologic diagnosis in patients with anaplastic gliomas.
Neurology
41
,
1741
-1744.

Hall, W.A. (

1998
) The safety and efficacy of stereotactic biopsy for intracranial lesions.
Cancer
82
,
1749
-1755.

Iacoangeli, M., Roselli, R., Prezioso, A., Scerrati, M., and Rossi, G.F. (

1993
) Staging of supratentorial hemispheric glioma using tumour extension, histopathological grade and extent of surgical resection.
Br. J. Surg.
80
,
1130
-1133.

Janny, P., Cure, H., Mohr, M., Heldt, N., Kwiatkowski, F., Lemaire, J.J., Plagne, R., and Rozan, R. (

1994
) Low grade supratentorial astrocytomas: Management and prognostic factors.
Cancer
73
,
1937
-1945.

Kepes, J.J. (

1994
) Pitfalls and problems in the histopathologic evaluation of stereotactic needle biopsy specimens.
Neurosurg. Clin. N. Am.
5
,
19
-33.

Kim, J.-H., and Gildenberg, P.L. (

1998
) Stereotactic biopsy. In: Gildenberg, P.L., and Tasker, R.R. (Eds.),
Textbook of Stereotactic and Functional Neurosurgery
. New York: McGraw-Hill. pp.
387
-396.

Kleihues, P., Volk, B., Anagnostopoulos, J., and Kiessling, M. (

1984
) Morphologic evaluation of stereotactic brain tumour biopsies.
Acta Neurochir. Suppl. (Wien)
33
,
171
-181.

Kreth, F.W., Warnke, P.C., Scheremet, R., and Ostertag, C.B. (

1993
) Surgical resection and radiation therapy versus biopsy and radiation therapy in the treatment of glioblastoma multiforme.
J. Neurosurg.
78
,
762
-766.

Levin, V.A., Prados, M.R., Wara, W.M., Davis, R.L., Gutin, P.H., Phillips, T.L., Lamborn, K., and Wilson, C.B. (

1995
) Radiation therapy and bromodeoxyuridine chemotherapy followed by procarbazine, lomustine, and vincristine for the treatment of anaplastic gliomas.
Int. J. Radiat. Oncol. Biol. Phys.
32
,
75
-83.

Lunsford, L.D., Somaza, S., Kondziolka, D., and Flickinger, J.C. (

1995
) Survival after stereotactic biopsy and irradiation of cerebral nonanaplastic, nonpilocytic astrocytoma.
J. Neurosurg.
82
,
523
-529.

Mittler, M.A., Walters, B.C., and Stopa, E.G. (

1996
) Observer reliability in histological grading of astrocytoma stereotactic biopsies.
J. Neurosurg.
85
,
1091
-1094.

Mundinger, F. (

1985
) CT stereotactic biopsy for optimizing the therapy of intracranial processes.
Acta Neurochir. Suppl. (Wien)
35
,
70
-74.

Nitta, T., and Sato, K. (

1995
) Prognostic implications of the extent of surgical resection in patients with intracranial malignant gliomas.
Cancer
75
,
2727
-2731.

Ostertag, C.B., Mennel, H.D., and Kiessling, M. (

1980
) Stereotactic biopsy of brain tumors.
Surg. Neurol.
14
,
275
-283.

Piepmeier, J., Christopher, S., Spencer, D., Byrne, T., Kim, J., Knisel, J.P., Lacy, J., Tsukerman, L., and Makuch, R. (

1996
) Variations in the natural history and survival of patients with supratentorial low-grade astrocytomas.
Neurosurgery
38
,
872
-879.

Pollack, I.F., Claassen, D., al-Shboul, Q., Janosky, J.E., and Deutsch, M. (

1995
) Low-grade gliomas of the cerebral hemispheres in children: An analysis of 71 cases.
J. Neurosurg.
82
,
536
-547.

Revesz, T., Scaravilli, F., Coutinho, L., Cockburn, H., Sacares, P., and Thomas, D.G. (

1993
) Reliability of histological diagnosis including grading in gliomas biopsied by image-guided stereotactic technique.
Brain
116
,
781
-793.

Rostomily, R.C., Spence, A.M., Duong, D., McCormick, K., Bland, M., and Berger, M.S. (

1994
) Multimodality management of recurrent adult malignant gliomas: Results of a phase II multiagent chemotherapy study and analysis of cytoreductive surgery.
Neurosurgery
35
,
378
-388.

Sawaya, R., Hammoud, M., Schoppa, D., Hess, K.R., Wu, S.Z., Shi, W.M., and Wildrick, D.M. (

1998
) Neurosurgical outcomes in a modern series of 400 craniotomies for treatment of parenchymal tumors.
Neurosurgery
42
,
1044
-1056.

Sawin, P.D., Hitchon, P.W., Follett, K.A., and Torner, J.C. (

1998
) Computed imaging-assisted stereotactic brain biopsy: A risk analysis of 225 consecutive cases.
Surg. Neurol.
49
,
640
-649.

Scerrati, M., and Rossi, G.F. (

1984
) The reliability of stereotactic biopsy.
Acta Neurochir. Suppl.
33
,
201
-205.

Sedan, R., Peragut, J.C., Farnarier, P.H., Hassoun, J., and Sethian, M. (

1984
) Intra-encephalic stereotactic biopsies (309 patients/318 biopsies).
Acta Neurochir. Suppl.
33
,
207
-210.

Shi, W.-M., Wildrick, D.M., and Sawaya, R. (

1998
) Volumetric measurement of brain tumors from MR imaging.
J. Neurooncol.
37
,
87
-93.

Smith, M.T., Ludwig, C.L., Godfrey, A.D., and Armbrustmacher, V.W. (

1983
) Grading of oligodendrogliomas.
Cancer
52
,
2107
-2114.

Vecht, C.J., Avezaat, C.J., van Putten, W.L., Eijkenboom, W.M., and Stefanko, S.Z. (

1990
) The influence of the extent of surgery on the neurological function and survival in malignant glioma: A retrospective analysis in 243 patients.
J. Neurol. Neurosurg. Psychiatry
53
,
466
-471.

Whiting, D.M., Barnett, G.H., Estes, M.L., Sila, C.A., Rudick, R.A., Hassenbusch, S.J., and Lanzieri, C.F. (

1992
) Stereotactic biopsy of non-neoplastic lesions in adults.
Cleve. Clin. J. Med.
59
,
48
-55.

Willems, J.G., and Alva-Willems, J.M. (

1984
) Accuracy of cytologic diagnosis of central nervous system neoplasms in stereotactic biopsies.
Acta Cytol.
28
,
243
-249.

Winger, M.J., Macdonald, D.R., and Cairncross, J.G. (

1989
) Supratentorial anaplastic gliomas in adults: The prognostic importance of extent of resection and prior low-grade glioma.
J. Neurosurg.
71
,
487
-493.

Author notes

Departments of Neurosurgery (R.J.J., D.A.-S., F.F.L, Z.L.G., W.M.S., D.M.W., R.S.) andPathology (G.N.F.), The University of Texas M. D. Anderson Cancer Center, Houston, TX 77030

© 2001 by the Society for Neuro-Oncology
Topic:
Issue Section:
Retrospective Clinical Study
Download all slides