Characterizing the performance of the nation's hospitals in the Hospital Outpatient Quality Reporting Program's imaging efficiency measures

Purpose: To describe the performance of the nation's hospitals in terms of the Hospital Outpatient Quality Reporting Program's imaging efficiency measures.

Methods: Data were obtained from the Hospital Compare website and reflect outpatient Medicare claims of 4,118 hospitals for 5 imaging efficiency metrics: (1) frequency of combination abdominal CT (performed with and without intravenous contrast); (2) combination chest CT (performed with and without intravenous contrast); (3) simultaneous brain/sinus CT; (4) mammography follow-up (diagnostic imaging after screening mammography); and (5) lumbar spine MRI for low back pain without prior conservative therapy. Metrics were summarized and compared with other hospital characteristics.

Results: Median frequency was 36.7% for lumbar spine MRI for low back pain and ranged from 1.6% to 7.8% for the remaining measures; however, extreme outliers were observed (maximal frequencies of 79.2%-95.2% for mammography follow-up and combination chest and abdominal CT). Essentially no correlation was found among measures, aside from combination abdominal and chest CT. For some measures, relatively poor performance was more commonly observed among critical access hospitals and physician-owned/proprietary hospitals, and less commonly observed among U.S. News & World Report "best" hospitals and primary residency teaching sites. Frequencies for combination abdominal and chest CT improved from 2013 to 2014 among hospitals with relatively poorer performance.

Conclusions: Although the imaging efficiency measures help identify individual hospitals and hospital categories with relatively inefficient imaging practices, they do not readily identify distinctly positively performing hospitals. Excess utilization was suggested for lumbar spine MRI. Frequency of combination abdominal and chest CT examinations improved over a short time interval.