Abstract
BACKGROUND AND PURPOSE: Sinus-preserving endovascular embolization was described as a promising treatment technique for dural arteriovenous fistulas. Our aim was to report our single-center experience in patients with dural arteriovenous fistulas who were treated with transarterial liquid embolization in combination with transvenous balloon-assisted protection of the affected venous sinus.
MATERIALS AND METHODS: A retrospective analysis of a prospectively collected data base was performed. Demographic and clinical data, angiographic features of the dural arteriovenous fistulas, procedural parameters, complications, treatment success, follow-up imaging, and clinical outcome were assessed.
RESULTS: Twenty-two patients were treated in 25 procedures. All patients were symptomatic, of whom 81.8% presented with tinnitus; 9.1%, with ocular symptoms; and 9.1%, with headache. Most fistulas were located at the transverse and/or sigmoid sinus. The most frequent fistula type was Cognard IIa+b (40.9%), followed by Cognard I (31.8%) and Cognard IIa (27.3%)/Borden I (59.1%), followed by Borden II (40.9%). The affected sinus could be preserved in all except for 1 patient in whom it was sacrificed in a second treatment procedure by coil embolization. The overall complete occlusion rate was 86.4%. The overall complication rate was 20%, with transient and permanent morbidity and mortality of 8%, 0%, and 0%, respectively. After a mean follow-up of 18 months, most patients (68.2%) achieved complete symptom remission, 27.3% showed symptom relief, and 4.6% had stable symptoms.
CONCLUSIONS: Transarterial liquid embolization of dural arteriovenous fistulas in combination with transvenous balloon-assisted protection of the venous sinus is feasible and safe and offers high rates of occlusion and of symptom remission.
ABBREVIATION:
- dAVF
- dural arteriovenous fistula
Dural arteriovenous fistulas (dAVFs) are pathologic, usually acquired connections between dural arteries and dural venous sinuses or cortical veins, resulting in arteriovenous shunting of blood. The 2 major types of clinical presentation are either hemorrhage, with corresponding neurologic deficits, or venous hypertension, with the latter potentially resulting in a variety of symptoms, such as headache, pulsatile tinnitus, visual disturbances, cognitive decline, or seizures.1
Endovascular treatment is considered effective for dAVFs.2,3 Various endovascular treatment techniques have been and are currently being used, using either a transarterial, transvenous, or combined approach.2 The armamentarium of embolic agents includes liquid embolic agents, such as cyanoacrylates and ethylene-vinyl copolymers, coils, and particles.2,3 In special situations, transient occlusion with balloon catheters can be used as an adjunct to conventional transarterial or transvenous embolization. When applied on the arterial side, they can be used for reduction of the blood flow of the fistula, for enhancement of distal migration of the embolic agent while simultaneously reducing the amount of reflux, and for improvement of embolization control.4⇓⇓–7 In the venous system, balloon catheters can be used for protecting the venous sinuses and nontarget veins from unwanted embolization.6,8⇓–10 In dAVFs with a high risk for venous nontarget embolization, especially fistulas at the transverse or sigmoid sinus, this aspect is of particular importance because nontarget embolization risks occlusion of functionally relevant venous drainage, potentially leading to venous congestion, venous infarction, or intracerebral hemorrhage.11,12 Transarterial embolization in combination with transvenous balloon protection is a promising approach for the effective treatment of dAVFs with prevention of nontarget embolization of the venous sinuses or normal superficial veins. So far, only a few studies on this technique with a relatively small number of patients are available.6,8,9,12,13
The aim of this study was to report our consecutive single-center experience of patients with dAVFs who were treated with transarterial liquid embolization in combination with transvenous balloon-assisted protection of the venous sinus and to present the feasibility, effectiveness, and safety of this treatment technique.
Materials and Methods
Clinical and Angiographic Analyses
Study approval and informed consent for data collection were provided by the local ethics committee and the patients, respectively.
A retrospective analysis of a prospectively maintained patient data base was performed to identify all subsequent patients with dAVFs who were treated with endovascular transarterial liquid embolization in combination with transvenous balloon-assisted protection of the venous sinus from January 2011 to November 2017.
Patient demographics, clinical presentation, and clinical follow-up were assessed and recorded by a board-certified neurologist, including preinterventional (on the day of the intervention) and postinterventional (at discharge and after 6 months) modified Rankin Scale scores. Angiographic features of the treated dAVFs were extracted, including location, type of fistula (according to the Cognard and Borden classifications14,15), and territories and number of the feeding arteries, by 2 experienced neuroradiologists (D.F.V. and M.A.M. with 5 and 12 years of experience, respectively), one of whom had no involvement in the treatment. Procedural parameters, such as the number of procedures, number of embolization positions, and the preservation of the venous sinus were documented. Peri- and postprocedural complications were assessed and graded as asymptomatic complications, transient symptomatic complications, and symptomatic complications with permanent neurologic deficits. The initial complete angiographic occlusion rate was assessed after the last treatment procedure. Overall complete occlusion was defined as complete occlusion of the dAVF at the last follow-up examination, diagnosed with digital subtraction angiography, which was performed 6 months after the last treatment, and/or MR imaging, which was performed before discharge and during the follow-up.
Patient Selection
Transarterial liquid embolization in combination with transvenous balloon-assisted protection of the affected venous sinus was chosen as the primary treatment technique in patients with patency and functioning of the affected sinus and location of the fistula point within the sinus wall. Contraindications for transvenous balloon-assisted protection of the sinus were nonpatency or nonfunctioning of the sinus (for example, due to high-grade stenosis or complete occlusion) or location of the fistula point in a sinus compartment, which can potentially be embolized selectively while preserving the sinus.16
Interventional Procedure
All interventions were performed with the patient under general anesthesia in a biplane angiography suite (Artis Q or Artis zee; Siemens, Erlangen, Germany). During the procedure, patients were anticoagulated using heparin to achieve an activated clotting time of >250 seconds. After puncture, a 6F introducer sheath was inserted into the right femoral artery and an 8F introducer sheath was inserted into the left femoral vein. Preinterventional bilateral diagnostic angiographies of the internal and external carotid arteries and of the vertebral arteries were performed. A schematic illustration of the treatment technique is shown in Fig 1. A compliant, dimethyl sulfoxide–compatible, venous remodeling balloon (Copernic RC, 8 × 80 or 10 × 80 mm; Balt Extrusion, Montmorency, France) was navigated via the transvenous route into the affected sinus covering the arterial feeders. Subsequently, a dimethyl sulfoxide–compatible microcatheter (Marathon microcatheter, Covidien, Irvine, California; or SONIC, Balt Extrusion) was navigated into the most promising arterial feeder with the aim of achieving a distal position as close as possible to the fistula point.
Schematic illustration of the treatment technique. A, The treatment technique is shown in the example of a Cognard I/Borden I dAVF located at the transverse and sigmoid sinuses with feeders from the occipital and middle meningeal arteries. B, After preinterventional diagnostic angiography, a balloon catheter (in black) is navigated into the affected sinus, and a microcatheter (in green) is navigated into the most promising feeder (in this example, the petrosquamosal branch of the middle meningeal artery). C, After superselective diagnostic angiographies via the microcatheter with and without balloon inflation, Onyx is injected under balloon deflation until the Onyx cast (in black) reaches the sinus. D, Subsequently, the balloon is inflated to prevent inadvertent embolization of the sinus and to enable retrograde embolization of the other arterial feeders. E, Onyx injection is continued under balloon inflation and deflation until embolization of all feeders is achieved. F, After the intervention, all feeding arteries are embolized and the sinus and the normal superficial veins (not shown) are preserved.
Superselective diagnostic angiographies via the selected arterial feeder with and without balloon inflation were performed to assess the distribution into other arterial feeders and to determine the optimal embolization and balloon position. If one balloon was not sufficient for complete occlusion of the sinus or for complete coverage of the fistula, a second balloon was inserted. Afterward, transarterial embolization was performed using Onyx 18 (Covidien) under a roadmap technique. Simultaneously, the venous balloon was inflated and deflated with a maximum inflation time of 5 minutes. The balloon inflation pressure was manually adjusted to prevent migration of the embolic agent into the main sinus lumen and to simultaneously achieve retrograde penetration into the arterial feeders. After termination of the embolization procedure, diagnostic angiographies were performed via the feeder territories for treatment control.
Results
Patient demographics, clinical presentation, and angiographic features of the treated dAVFs are summarized in Table 1.
Patient demographics, clinical presentation, and angiographic features of the treated dAVFsa
Twenty-two patients diagnosed with dAVFs who were treated with endovascular transarterial liquid embolization in combination with transvenous balloon-assisted protection of the venous sinus from January 2011 to November 2017 were analyzed. All these patients were symptomatic, of whom 81.8% had tinnitus; 9.1%, ocular symptoms; 9.1%, headache; and 22.7%, other symptoms. One patient (4.6%) presented with an intracerebral hemorrhage. The fistulas were located at the transverse and/or sigmoid sinus (86.4%), the sagittal superior sinus (9.1%), or the marginal sinus (4.6%). Most treated fistulas were low-grade without cortical venous reflux (59.1%). According to the Cognard classification, the most frequent fistula type was IIa+b (40.9%), followed by I (31.8%) and IIa (27.3%). According to the Borden classification, the most frequent fistula type was I (59.1%), followed by II (40.9%). The middle meningeal artery, the occipital artery (both 95.5%), and dural branches of the internal carotid artery (86.4%) were the predominant arterial supplies.
Procedural parameters, treatment results, follow-up, and outcome are summarized in Table 2. An illustration of a representative case is shown in Fig 2.
Procedural parameters, treatment results, follow-up, and outcomea
Illustration of a representative case. A, Right external carotid artery angiogram shows a Cognard IIa+b/Borden II dAVF located at the transverse and sigmoid sinuses with multiple feeding arteries out of numerous vascular territories. B, Right internal carotid artery angiogram shows dural branches of the internal carotid artery feeding the fistula (black arrow). C, Venous phase of B. Note the proximity of the fistula point (black arrow in B) to the junction of the vein of Labbé and of the inferior temporal veins into the sinus (black arrow). For successful treatment of the dAVF, the fistula point should be embolized while simultaneously preserving these veins. D, Superselective angiogram without balloon inflation via the feeder that was selected for embolization, the mastoid branch of the occipital artery (microcatheter tip marked with an open arrow). There is drainage via the sinus (white arrows) and only slight filling of the adjacent feeders (black arrow). E, Lateral x-ray shows the inflated balloon. F, Superselective angiogram after balloon inflation (microcatheter tip marked with an open arrow). Due to the temporary occlusion of the sinus, which shows only minimal enhancement at the edge of the balloon (white arrow) at the junction of the vein of Labbé and the inferior temporal veins (C), nearby feeders show marked filling of contrast agent (black arrows). The angiograms with the inflated balloon serve as a test injection to estimate the distribution of the subsequently injected liquid embolic agent. G, Onyx cast after embolization with distribution of the embolic agent in all feeding artery territories. Common carotid artery angiogram of the arterial (H) and venous (I) phases 6 months after treatment shows complete occlusion of the fistula and patency of the venous sinuses and the normal superficial veins.
Twenty-five treatment procedures were performed. In all patients, the treatment technique of the first procedure was transarterial Onyx embolization in combination with transvenous balloon protection. Two of the 3 patients who needed an additional treatment were again treated using the same technique, while for 1 patient, the second treatment consisted of coil embolization of the affected sinus. The reason for sinus occlusion in this patient was progressive thrombosis of the sinus, which was exclusively draining the fistula and was no longer involved in the normal venous drainage of the cranium. In 4 patients, 2 balloon catheters were required for adequate occlusion of the venous sinus or for complete coverage of the fistula. Most fistulas were embolized via the middle meningeal artery (80.0%); the second most frequently selected feeder was the occipital artery (24.0%).
The initial complete angiographic occlusion rate was 63.6%, followed by 5 more complete spontaneous occlusions during the follow-up period, resulting in an overall complete occlusion rate of 86.4%. One of the 3 patients with residual fistula on angiography had a low-grade fistula (Cognard IIa/Borden I) and showed complete symptom remission at the last clinical examination. The remaining 2 patients refused further treatment because of symptom relief. For the 5 patients with spontaneous occlusion after treatment, the mean time from treatment to diagnosis of spontaneous occlusion was 106 days, ranging from 7 days to 14 months.
After a mean follow-up of 18 months, most patients (68.2%) were free of symptoms, while 27.3% showed symptom relief and 4.6% had stable symptoms compared with the preinterventional status. Five patients still had symptoms (symptom relief for 4 patients and stable symptoms for 1 patient) despite complete occlusion of the fistula. These patients had nonpulsatile tinnitus (n = 2), headache (n = 2), and residual symptoms after severe venous congestion (n = 1). No patient died during the follow-up.
Postinterventional diagnostic angiography was performed in 77.2% of cases. From the patients without follow-up DSA, 3 patients refused further invasive diagnostic imaging because of complete symptom remission, and for 2 patients, follow-up DSA is still pending. Postinterventional MR imaging was performed in all patients.
Five procedure-related complications occurred, resulting in an overall complication rate of 20% (with respect to the number of treatment procedures). We recorded the following complications: 2 small infarctions, 2 small subdural hemorrhages (most likely caused by vessel perforation during navigation of the microcatheter into the respective arterial feeder or during traction of the microcatheter after embolization), and 1 small intracerebral hemorrhage (<1 cm in diameter). In 1 patient with a small venous infarction, inadvertent embolization of the proximal part of the vein of Labbé could be identified as a suspected reason for the complication. For the small intracerebral hemorrhage, which was detected on a peri-interventional conebeam CT scan during the treatment of a patient with a Cognard IIa/Borden I dAVF, stasis in a small temporal vein, caused by the temporary balloon occlusion, could be identified as a suspected reason for the complication. Three complications were asymptomatic, and 2 complications were symptomatic. The 2 patients with symptomatic complications had headaches, which were declining until discharge and no longer present 6 months after treatment. No complication with permanent neurologic deficits was recorded. No procedure-related cranial neuropathies were observed.
Discussion
Endovascular therapy has become the treatment of choice for most intracranial dAVFs and has considerably improved in recent years, which can—among other factors—be attributed to the introduction of new treatment techniques based on new devices, such as embolic agents, microcatheters, and balloon catheters.2,3,17 More recently, the strategy of neuroendovascular treatment aims to eliminate the respective pathology with preservation of the surrounding healthy vasculature. A promising technique for avoiding inadvertent occlusion of normal veins during transarterial embolization of dAVFs, which was first described by Shi et al13 in 2009, is the transient placement of a balloon in the affected venous sinus.6,8⇓–10 The studies with the highest case numbers reporting this technique are those by Piechowiak et al6 and Ertl et al12 in 2017. Piechowiak et al6 conducted a retrospective study of 9 patients with fistulas of the transverse and sigmoid sinuses who were treated using a technique that is similar to the technique described here. However, they used balloon assistance on both the venous and the arterial sides. Ertl et al12 compared sinus-occluding and sinus-preserving endovascular treatment techniques for dAVFs, reporting on a subgroup of 11 patients treated with transarterial Onyx embolization combined with transvenous balloon-assisted protection of the venous sinus. In our retrospectively analyzed and prospectively maintained data base, 22 patients treated with transarterial liquid embolization in combination with transvenous balloon-assisted protection of the venous sinus were analyzed, and the feasibility, effectiveness, and safety of this treatment technique were investigated.
Except for 1 patient in our study in whom the affected sinus was occluded by coil embolization, preservation of the sinus could be achieved in all procedures. In the above-mentioned studies, the postinterventional patency of the respective sinus was not specifically reported.6,12,13
The described embolization technique promotes the preservation of the normal venous structures. In addition, another major advantage of the technique is described here. Not only is the arterial feeder through which the injection is performed being embolized but feeders from other arterial territories with connection to the respective sinus segment are also embolized in a retrograde manner by migration of embolic agent along the balloon and the sinus wall into the feeders. As a result, feeding arteries that are difficult or technically impossible to catheterize can be easily embolized and the number of arterial feeders to be catheterized can be reduced, potentially lowering the risk of periprocedural technical complications and also reducing the procedure time. Accordingly, in most cases in our study, only 1 embolization position was necessary for complete or near-complete embolization of the dAVFs. This is important because most of the dAVFs of the transverse and sigmoid sinuses have multiple feeders,18 as was the case in our series, in which 86% of the treated fistulas had >20 arterial feeding arteries. In this context, besides the facilitation of embolization of feeding arteries, this treatment technique also bears the risk of inadvertent embolization of cortical veins draining into the sinus. To prevent this complication, these veins must be carefully observed during the embolization, and if necessary, the balloon must be repositioned or another arterial feeder selected for embolization.
The overall complete occlusion rate of 86% in our series is comparable with the results of Piechowiak et al,6 who achieved complete occlusion or substantial flow reduction in 89% of patients treated with balloon-assistance on the arterial and venous sides. Similarly, Ertl et al12 reported a complete occlusion rate of 71% for sinus-preserving endovascular treatments (not further subdivided with respect to the specific treatment technique).
Most of the fistulas in our series were low-grade without cortical venous reflux. For this type of fistula, the risk of bleeding is relatively low; therefore, substantial relief or complete remission of symptoms is the main aim of the treatment.19 The high rate of complete symptom remission and symptom relief of 95% in our study is in accordance with the results of recently published studies and underlines the effectiveness of endovascular embolization for the treatment of this type of dAVF.3,6,12
A significantly lower complication rate for sinus-preserving than for sinus-occluding techniques has been reported in a recently published study (0% versus 33%), however, with a higher rate of permanent fistula occlusion for sinus-occluding techniques.12 In our study, the overall complication rate was 20% without any permanent neurologic deficits. Of the 5 complications that occurred in the present study, 2 can be attributed to the balloon occlusion of the venous sinus: 1 case of venous infarction due to inadvertent embolization of the proximal part of the vein of Labbé (facilitated by the balloon occlusion) and 1 case of intracerebral hemorrhage due to stasis of a small temporal vein caused by the temporary balloon occlusion itself. For the second patient who developed a venous infarction, no specific reason could be identified; however, the 2 above-mentioned mechanisms might also have contributed to this complication. To prevent procedure-related complications, as mentioned above, special attention should be paid to cortical veins draining into the affected sinus because inadvertent occlusion of these structures (both by inadvertent embolization and by too long temporary balloon occlusion) can lead to venous congestion and/or hemorrhage. The low rate of symptomatic complications is in line with data from other studies of sinus-preserving and sinus-occluding techniques with and without balloon-assistance.3,5,6,12,20
A potential limitation of this study is its relative low case number. However, to the best of our knowledge, this is the largest study reporting on this treatment technique. Furthermore, the study was conducted in a single institution with retrospective analysis of prospectively maintained data, which is a potential limitation on the study findings.
Conclusions
Transarterial liquid embolization in combination with transvenous balloon-assisted protection of the venous sinus is feasible and safe for the treatment of dAVFs and offers high rates of complete occlusion and of complete symptom remission or relief. Further studies with higher case numbers and long-term follow-up are necessary to further assess the value of this treatment technique.
Footnotes
Disclosures: Dominik F. Vollherbst—UNRELATED: Travel/Accommodations/Meeting Expenses Unrelated to Activities Listed: MicroVention, Stryker*. Christian Ulfert—UNRELATED: Travel/Accommodations/Meeting Expenses Unrelated to Activities Listed: MicroVention, Stryker. Christian Herweh—UNRELATED: Consultancy: Brainomix, Oxford, UK, Comments: <€10,000. Simon Nagel—UNRELATED: Consultancy: Brainomix, Boehringer Ingelheim; Payment for Lectures Including Service on Speakers Bureaus: Pfizer, Medtronic, Bayer AG. Martin Bendszus—UNRELATED: Board Membership: Data and Safety Monitoring Board for Vascular Dynamics, Guerbet, Boehringer Ingelheim; Consultancy: Codman, Roche Diagnostics, Guerbet, Boehringer Ingelheim, Braun; Grants/Grants Pending: DFG, Hopp Foundation, Novartis, Siemens, Guerbet, Stryker, Covidien*; Payment for Lectures Including Service on Speakers Bureaus: Novartis, Roche Diagnostics, Guerbet, Teva Pharmaceutical Industries, Bayer AG, Codman. Markus A. Möhlenbruch—UNRELATED: Board Membership: Codman; Consultancy: Medtronic, MicroVention, Stryker; Payment for Lectures Including Service on Speakers Bureaus: Medtronic, MicroVention, Stryker. *Money paid to the institution.
References
- Received January 15, 2018.
- Accepted after revision March 5, 2018.
- © 2018 by American Journal of Neuroradiology
Jump to section
Related Articles
Cited By...
- First clinical multicenter experience with the new Scepter Mini microballoon catheter
- Transarterial Treatment of Cranial Dural Arteriovenous Fistulas: The Role of Transarterial and Transvenous Balloon-Assisted Embolization
- The Influence of Angioarchitectural Features on the Success of Endovascular Embolization of Cranial Dural Arteriovenous Fistulas with Onyx