Table 1:

Correctness percentage by reviewer and ICA target component

ReviewerICA ComponentTop ChoicesNo. (% Correctness)95% CIs
1Overall72.09%66.12%–77.39%
120Top 128 (65.12%)49.01%–78.55%
120Top 232 (74.42%)58.53%–85.96%
120Top 333 (76.74%)61.00%–87.72%
150Top 125 (58.14%)42.21%–72.63%
150Top 233 (76.74%)61.00%–87.72%
150Top 335 (81.40%)66.08%–91.08%
2Overall50.39%44.13%–56.63%
220Top 116 (37.21%)23.39%–53.28%
220Top 223 (53.49%)37.83%–68.53%
220Top 324 (55.81%)40.01%–70.59%
250Top 115 (34.88%)21.45%–50.99%
250Top 224 (55.81%)40.01%–70.59%
250Top 328 (65.12%)49.01%–78.55%
3Overall55.04%48.74%–61.18%
320Top 122 (51.16%)35.68%–66.44%
320Top 226 (60.47%)44.45%–74.63%
320Top 326 (60.47%)44.45%–74.63%
350Top 118 (41.86%)27.37%–57.79%
350Top 224 (55.81%)40.01%–70.59%
350Top 326 (60.47%)44.45%–74.63%